This is my longest yet, but it is very important. Please read entirely.
Something I’ve spent a lot of timing thinking about since the beginning of fall semester is the issue we have with the Trustee Leadership Scholarship (TLS). For those who do not know, there are some students, including myself, who have been trying to change a requirement for our TLS, which rewards student leadership with a $500 per semester scholarship. The issue with this scholarship is students are required to apply for FAFSA (financial aid) in order to be eligible. This is a problem for more than one reason.
First it is a merit based scholarship, which means you are being rewarded for something tangible, such as leadership on campus. It is NOT A NEED based scholarship which is based off your or your family’s income and assets. (Thus requiring tax information & Fafsa application) Requiring FAFSA for merit based scholarships is not uncommon because for some scholarships schools use financial aid first then scholarship money next. If financial aid covers your tuition and books then the scholarship goes back to the foundation. BUT the leadership scholarship is different, it is applied first (as it should be). Therefore the school is only blocking certain students (students whose parents refuse to file for fafsa, or students who don’t have the necessary documents) from applying and receiving a very helpful and honorable scholarship.
Secondly, this policy appears to violate the mission statement and shared values of our college and restricts opportunities to students who are deserving. But I have received word from a respectable source stating money from the state cannot be given to undocumented students.<-------Yes, that’s a period at the end of that sentence. That statement has led to a few interesting conclusions, one ending in discrimination, and the other with laws already being broken by Colleges across the state and probably the whole country.
I'm not going to get into the details of these conclusions at this time because we have yet to exhaust all of our options and want to wait and see how this plays out during the next few months. One thing I will say is I have yet to see a document which clearly details the awarding of funds to undocumented students in college as illegal and even if it was illegal, I would be wholeheartedly against it. The source of education funds in this state comes from property tax, which immigrants pay into whether it’s through a mortgage and paying property tax or by paying rent (property tax is built into rent). So the student and their family pay into property tax and they pay tuition as well, yet I'm told it’s illegal.
I personally feel if it is indeed illegal that it would be a great law to break. It is not in the best interest of our community, and it doesn’t align with our mission statement or shared values! Here are quotes from the former mentioned school policies....
Mission statement
3. “Improving success milestones among key focus populations: first-time, developmental, adult, black and Latino students”
5. “Fostering a spirit of inquiry to increase understanding of racial, ethnic and global diversity, and of domestic and world cultures”
6. “Ensuring key focus populations have equal access to learning opportunities.”
Shared Values
“Equity. We believe that everyone must have an equal opportunity to grow through learning and pledge to provide all who take part in our learning activities with the opportunities and supports needed for success.”
“Respect for Diversity. All constituencies are important to achieving our vision. Therefore, we must respect the unique and diverse perspectives each person offers and embrace those differences as the means for developing the strongest learning community possible. We promote individual growth and a positive sense of self-worth for all members of the college community. “
Wow….that last sentence gets me every time. As you can see the position our Community College currently takes is in-between contradiction and hypocrisy. How can we tell student leaders, “sorry we know it’s not right but it is what it is?!!!” We live in a diverse community. We need to educate our students, we need to reward and encourage outstanding students more now than ever before. In most families, an extra $500 allows the repairing of a car in the winter, or covering an emergency visit to the doctor, or food, or clothes, or rent.
I want this policy changed. And so do others. It is immoral, unethical, and I would argue it is discrimination. If there are any of you out there who think it won't be fair to the students who have the necessary documents and chance losing out on a scholarship to an undocumented student....get this, in the last 10 semester only three times have all 16 scholarships been handed out! Would you rather let scholarship money sit un-used, or create competition at a position where it’s desperately needed?
So, I guess it starts with us. Our laws are not set up to serve the best interest of our community and our College has an opportunity to set the tone for change in this area. This is not the time to hold back some of our best students! It’s actually time we do something great and take a stand for our students, even if it means breaking a law. Please let me know how you feel about this and feel free to contact me at dgood@elgin.edu if you’d like more information. If a student is willing to put in hard work and dedicate time to a leadership role I feel we, as a school community, should help support those students regardless where they have come from. This requirement is a detriment.