Pulcherissma Olive (me)
says:
i bid thou
a swell wizard independence day!!!
Margaret (my brilliant friend) says:
Why, thank you, Madame Pulcherissma
Olive!
Pulcherissma Olive
says:
so, what are
you twilight questions???
Margaret says:
I am trying to formulate them,
actually.
=)
(Sheepish smile.)
Pulcherissma Olive
says:
mk
Margaret says:
Basically, I am trying to figure out
why Edward Cullen is so appealing.
And why
people's affections for him seem to
toy with the boundaries of what is fictional and what is not.
Now, I can imagine why he is appealing
in a practical sense ; )
Pulcherissma Olive
says:
because he
says the exact right thing at the right time. he looks like a Greek
god, he's smart, he speaks other languages, he plays the piano, he's
got money up the wazu, he drives a safe but fast car.
edward cullen
is the blue print for a perfect boyfriend, mysterious and a bad boy
(vampire) but still safe (he sparkles)
when compared
with other vampires, edward looks like a fairy though. but other vampire
can be scary. take for instance the vampires in true blood. while sookie
finds them attractive, she still knows that there is vampire in bill
and that sometimes scares her.
her
relationship
with eric is even more interesting. eric doesn't try to mainstream and
not eat humans. he doesn't deny his vampireness and never hides it from
sookie, i think that something like this is appealing in a sense of
honesty about him
girls that
like vampires like them to have a side of humanity about them, and
edward
has a lot of human in him, especially since he doesn't eat people
buffy loved
angel because he was cursed with a soul, she didn't start liking spike
(and eventually falling in love with him in my opinion) till he started
acting less like a vampire and more like a human
a pure vampire
scares us
there is no
team aro. . . because aro doesn't act like a human, he acts like a
vampire,
which is what he is!
Margaret says:
: )
Awesome.
Do you mind if I quote any of this?
Pulcherissma Olive
says:
go for it!
Margaret says:
Thanks!
I have a few more, though.
Pulcherissma Olive
says:
i've spent
a lot of time thinking about this, as you can tell
Margaret says:
: )
I appreciate it!
You're not one of those fangirls who
would be like
"OMG he is hottt."
You have intelligent answers.
Pulcherissma Olive
says:
well, i mean,
he is hot, but vampires are much more complicated and the team edward
thing has a reason
plus, moms
feel a hell of a lot more comfortable around a toothless sparkly 17
year old (edward) than they do around a 1000 fanged viking (eric
northman,
who kicks edward's butt in just about everything)
Margaret says:
: )
True.
Pulcherissma Olive
says:
even my mom
is a lot more accepting of twilight than of buffy and especially of
true blood
i don't even
talk about true blood or buffy around her
Margaret says:
Yes, I could see where those might
be controversial.
Do you think
that the fact that Edward is so
obviously
fictional
(being a vampire, which is a creature
that cannot exist)
makes it easier to engage with him
and become engrossed with him as a character?
Pulcherissma Olive
says:
i think that
it’s the blend of fiction (the vampire in him) and nonfiction (his
human side) that make him so engrossing. on one hand he is the amazing,
god of mythology who can save you and make your world magical, but he
also goes to high school, which is something that every single girl
in America can relate to. his ordinariness combined with his supernatural aspect
is what makes him so appealing
Margaret says:
That's interesting.
That contradicts one of my articles
a little bit, which I like.
: )
Pulcherissma Olive
says:
what does the
article say?
Margaret says:
Well, it basically says that readers
engage better with works that are obviously fictional.
The fictionality is kind of like a
safe-guard.
So I was theorizing
that what makes Edward so safe, in
a way, is the fact that he simply cannot exist.
Pulcherissma Olive
says:
well, i think
that readers like fiction, but want to be able to relate to a nonfiction
aspect.
see, i think
that edward is so appreciated because he is more ordinary (and less
vampiric) than most vampires. he is so human, he could almost exist.
angel, spike,
bill, eric, louis, lestat, armand, they cannot come out in the day,
and the more strict the vampire, the scarier. interview with a vampire
scared the pants off of me because louis, lestat, and armand were really
vampirc! they slept in coffins, they didn't care about souls or humans
in any way. louis has a bit of the whole soul searching aspect, but
not a whole lot
bill and eric
do care more for humans, especially bill, (true blood) but they still
burst into flames in the sunlight, they can be staked, they burn when
touched with silver. angel and spike can be awake in the day and so
they really aren't scary, edward just walks out into the sunlight
so i think
that the appeal of edward comes from having so little vampire and so
much human in him, but with that hint of vampire
that’s why
i like it when edward is a badass, i thought that he should have fought
james in the meadow
he should have
changed bella once he realized that he loved her
because that
is what a vampire would do!!!
Margaret says:
: )
You have given me a page of notes.
Okay, so
Pulcherissma Olive
says:
and i have
a blog post!
Margaret says:
in your initial statement of why
Edward
is amazing
(and I would love to see the blog!)
Pulcherissma Olive
says:
i'll send you
the link
Margaret says:
you say that it is because of this
combination of human characteristics.
Which could never possibly be united
in one person.
Pulcherissma Olive
says:
only in fabio
and johnny depp
Margaret says:
: )
Pulcherissma Olive
says:
Margaret says:
Hee!
Do you think those are signs of his
fictionality that make him appealing?
Aside from the vampire-ness?
Would he be less of who he is if he
didn't, say, know the languages or play the piano?
Just the fact that all of those traits
are combined in one tremendous person?
Pulcherissma Olive
says:
oh certainly!
any woman would love to have their guy act like edward. everything that
edward has done (languages, piano, etc) have built him into this
greek-god
of a man
the fact that
he is such an accomplished man along with a safe vampire are the ticket
stephenie meyer
took the idea of an ideal man, made him young, gorgeous, fast, strong,
telepathic, and a little bit of the bad boy
and poof (with
a bit of fairy dust) you get edward masen cullen
did you know
that vampires really like fairies?
Margaret says:
Naw.
You're kidding.
Pulcherissma Olive
says:
nope! in the
southern vampire mysteries, part of why sookie is so attractive is
because
she is part fairy!
Margaret says:
Oh wow.
: )
Pulcherissma Olive
says:
yep!
Margaret says:
If you had to pick your favorite thing
about Edward, what would it be?
Just one trait.
Pulcherissma Olive
says:
id' probably say
in eclipse when bella is worried about if edward has ever gone for
anyone
else and he says : sleep, my bella. dream happy dreams. you are the
only one who has ever touched my heart. it will always be yours. sleep,
my only love. or his meteor quote in new moon when he says that his
life was a black moonless night till bella shot across the sky lighting
everything in his world
so his favorite
trait would be the total and complete way that he loves, not just bella,
but his whole family
i love the meadow scene
in twilight too
the heroin quote is
good too
you are exactly my
brand of heroin
that gets me every
time
Margaret says:
: )